George Ellery Hale was an early and important pioneer of Solar Research. In the early 19th Century, in Pasadena, coincidently, the present location of NASA`s JPL ( Jet Propulsion Laboratory ) Hale constructed, one of the most advanced Solar Telescopes of the time, on the San Gabriel Mountains. Hale equipped it with the latest spectrographic detectors and equipment, and proceeded to isolate the spectrographic signatures of the element present in the Solar spectrum.
Hale, a renowned Solar photographer, was able to image sunspots in minute detail , and in June 1908 he made an important discovery. That discovery was, that magenticc fields were present in the vicinity of Sunspots.
Hale then made one of the most fundamental errors that has ever been made in the annals of Solar Astrophysics , and everyone including the peers of the day bought Hales hypothesis. That error was to lead to the development of numerous flawed Solar Models, and thereby inhibited the development of Solar, Stellar and Galactic astrophysics for the rest of the 19th century, the 20th Century and beyond.
The knock on effect was to denyAstrophysicists an important tool , to resolve problems , and anomalies of planetary system formation, Galactic type formation, and local and large scale Galactic structure. For a Century and several,decades, the resolution of anomalous findings was obscured by this mistake.
The mistake was to assume that the prescence of magnetic fields in the vicinity of Sunspots, was the cause of Sunspots. When the inverse is true. Sunspots are the cause of magnetic fields.
In 1908 the mechanics of atomic structure, fission and fusion were not available to assist Hale and the Astrophysicists of the day, in the interpretation of the entirely new Solar phenomena.
In the pre fusion fission era, we cannot therefore penalise Hale or his peers, and their acceptance at what appeared to them to be " the definitive solution" available at that time. That Solar Astrophysicists missed the boat , in the light of a Century of Astrophysics, is a mystery to me. Kevin Wilson
George Ellery Hale was an early and important pioneer of Solar Research. In the early 19th Century, in Pasadena, coincidently, the present location of NASA`s JPL ( Jet Propulsion Laboratory ) Hale constructed, one of the most advanced Solar Telescopes of the time, on the San Gabriel Mountains. Hale equipped it with the latest spectrographic detectors and equipment, and proceeded to isolate the spectrographic signatures of the element present in the Solar spectrum.