Scandal! Scientist Makes Honest Mistake, Humbly Retracts Supersolidity Result
You may have heard of superfluids and superconductors, so why not supersolids? In 2004 Moses Chan and Eunseong Kim thought they had discovered that super-cooled helium ice could essentially walk through walls – a defining characteristic of a supersolid.
The experiment was to make a cylinder with tiny nanopores in its walls, fill the pores with solid helium ice, suspend the cylinder from a torsional spring, and then give it a little twist. Like a kid on a swing set, the cylinder started rotating back and forth, with a frequency depending on its mass. As they…