Skip to main content

Test announcement

Announcement here about some event or update. Or maybe link to promoted article. 

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Culture
    • Humor
    • Mathematics
    • Random Thoughts
    • Science & Society
    • Sports Science
    • Technology
  • Earth Sciences
    • Atmospheric
    • Energy
    • Environment
    • Geology
    • Oceanography
    • Paleontology
  • Life Sciences
    • Ecology & Zoology
    • Evolution
    • Immunology
    • Microbiology
    • Neuroscience
  • Medicine
    • Aging
    • Cancer Research
    • Clinical Research
    • Pharmacology
    • Public Health
    • Vision
  • Physical Sciences
    • Aerospace
    • Applied Physics
    • Chemistry
    • Optics
    • Physics
    • Space
  • Social Sciences
    • Anthropology
    • Archaeology
    • Philosophy & Ethics
    • Psychology
    • Science History
  • Contributors
X XD

User menu

  • Log in

NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine Called Pluto A Planet Again: He's Not Wrong

By Hank Campbell in Science 2.0
August 30, 2019
Profile picture for user Hank
Submitted by Hank on Fri, 08/30/2019 - 07:27
Old NID
241260

NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine laid it on the table recently; to him, Pluto is a planet. News outlets are calling him out, saying the "official governing body" does not agree.

The Paris-based  International Astronomy Union (IAU) is not really astronomy’s official governing body any more than NASA is. They often claim to be but they are a few hundred astronomers. They do not determine official designations any more than a few scholars with expert in CRISPR at a National Academy can tell FDA to stop treating harmless gene editing in plant varietals as a new drug in the regulatory scheme.

Pluto was demoted by a vote of 237 people, not the science community. It was widely derided in jokes at the time.

There is no official governing body for astronomy, that is why if you want to spend $1 and have an asteroid named after your kid, you can. IAU will say such a name is not official, but their arbitrary ruling on Pluto, and the fact that 98% of astronomers had nothing to do with it, show how little clout they have. There is also no official government body of cancer, which is why you can still buy bacon and drink hot tea even though IARC statisticians (also in France) did their best to try and link those to cancer.

Pluto could be one of 9 planets, or one of 13 - the IAU botched their effort to be meaningful that badly when they created a new arbitrary definition to replace an old one.

Bridenstine should not say 'that is how I learned it' as a rationale, people my age were also duped into believing "nuclear winter" was real and that NRDC was a legitimate environmental group. But while he's not right to say Pluto is a planet, he is not wrong either. 

IAU has its own internal politics. Many inside know their own new definition is batty, but they do not want to stand up to insiders who will shout them down. Yet until they come up with a legitimate definition of planet, no one is going to rush to agree with them.

Donate

Please donate so science experts can write for the public.

At Science 2.0, scientists are the journalists, with no political bias or editorial control. We can't do it alone so please make a difference.

Donate with PayPal button 
We are a nonprofit science journalism group operating under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code that's educated over 300 million people.

You can help with a tax-deductible donation today and 100 percent of your gift will go toward our programs, no salaries or offices.

Latest reads

Article teaser image
No, Trump’s Executive Orders Can’t Cancel Your Rights.
Donald Trump does not have the power to rescind either constitutional amendments or federal laws by mere executive order, no matter how strongly he might wish otherwise. No president of the United…
Article teaser image
The US Discourages Pregnant Women From Drinking Alcohol - Vegetarian Diets Are Worse
The Biden administration recently issued a new report showing causal links between alcohol and cancer, and it's about time. The link has been long-known, but alcohol carcinogenic properties have been…
Article teaser image
In British Iron Age Culture, Margaret Thatcher Was The Norm
In British Iron Age society, land was inherited through the female line and husbands moved to live with the wife’s community. Strong women like Margaret Thatcher resulted.That was inferred due to DNA…

More reads

Featured Image

TED And TikTok: SciComm Student Credibility Ranking Shows Future Science Journalism May Be In Trouble

America doesn't have a science literacy problem, at least in a relative sense. Though only 29 percent of American adults can demonstrate good science literacy, that is still enough to be number one…
Featured Image

Marriage Is Healthy For Men But Bad For Women? Results Show The Opposite

Men who live alone and have a smaller social network are less likely to be obese than women who have the same lifestyle, according to results found in the Canadian Longitudinal Study on Aging survey.
Featured Image

Holding Global Warming Deniers Accountable

Like it or not, human-enhanced global warming is an established scientific fact.
Featured Image

Debunking: A President Of The US Could Order A Nuclear Attack At A Moments Notice On A Whim

Summary: Legally the president makes the decision and everyone else then scurries around and follows his or her orders; in practice it's not going to be that simple in peace time especially. He or…

Footer

  • About Us
  • Copyright and Removal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms